A couple weekends back I planned a reconnect day for a couple friends, and we got together to relax over wine and snacks, which is when I got the idea for this Steak Bruschetta appetizer that y’all won’t quit Instagram-messaging me about!
So, today I’m sharing how I made the sweet and smoky roasted piquillo pepper sauce (way easier than you think because I just use a jar of roasted piquillo peppers), how I designed it to be held for hours before a party, and how we can make it look fun and festive for holidays and gatherings!
I think we all know by now that Texans like me love beef, and a dish that I am bonkers over and try to hunt down on high-end restaurant appetizer menus is steak tartare! (Stay with me, this recipe isn’t for steak tartare, but it helps understand why this steak bruschetta recipe works.) 😛
When I was a professional chef, tartare was a dish I was in charge of at La Mansion Del Rio in San Antonio and I adored developing new tartare experiences. In all of it’s forms beef pairs well with onion, garlic, rich and creamy sauces, roasted peppers, herbs, a bit of crunch, a pop of acidity from vinegar or lemon, and of course a little toasted baguette never hurts.
Unfortunately, it’s hard to find tartare outside of 4 star steakhouses, so when I get a craving for it it often goes unfulfilled. That’s why I put this dish together—only here we will be using seared medium-rare filet mignon bathed in a creamy piquillo pepper aioli, for a more approachable bruschetta topping that everyone will be happy to try.
Because it’s cold and rainy outside, I am pan-searing my thick-cut filet mignon steaks, but this dish would be delicious made with grilled steak as well. If filet mignon is unavailable or too expensive, sirloin steak is an excellent substitute. The best approach to a hard and crusty sear on your steaks is always to season liberally with salt and pepper, garlic powder, and onion powder.
Sear in a heavy bottomed pan with a high-smoke point oil such as avocado oil, sunflower oil, safflower oil, etc, over medium high heat.
This 12-Inch All-Clad Skillet really helps the beef develop a perfect crust for all my recipes. Because they are expensive, I encourage people to just buy one that you can use when searing meat and chicken for all of your favorite dishes, but if that still out of your price range you can’t beat a good quality cast-iron skillet.
Cook for 3-4 minutes on each side. The sear should be beautifully golden brown and the inside should remain hot pink.
Remove the steaks and rest for 12 minutes. For the love of all that is good and holy, DO NOT cut into the steaks before letting them rest or the juices that give you so much flavor will run out! Lay the seared filet mignon out on a cutting board and slice into thin slices. Here is the Chef Knife I have and love as well as the Sharpener I use to keep all of my knives razor sharp.
When you have made your slices, cut again into 1/2 inch morsels…
Add the morsels of seared steak to a bowl and combine with the caramelized sweet onion, and fresh herbs. Chill in the refrigerator while we start the piquillo pepper sauce.
How to Make the Piquillo Pepper Sauce Recipe:
The piquillo peppers that I am using in the sauce for the steak bruschetta are grilled and roasted, jarred piquillo peppers. These roasted peppers are not hot at all. They have a sweet and smoky flavor and if you cannot find them, an adequate piquillo pepper substitute is ordinary roasted red bell peppers in the jar.
I prefer piquillo peppers for this recipe because they have a richer flavor and the flesh is consistently thin and delicate, which provides a consistent texture for the piquillo pepper topping. (The pretty red nibbles I put on top of the final bruschetta before serving.)
This is what my jar looks like. I am not personally attached to this brand of piquillo peppers, it’s just what my Sprouts sells. I have also seen piquillo peppers on the olive bar at grocery stores. Here is a jar on Amazon if you cannot find it locally.
Here is what they look like when you open it up! They are very fine, silky roasted peppers and that gorgeous red color really gets my appetite going…
In a blender, you’ll add all of the ingredients and blend well. That’s it! What looks like a very daunting, cheffy recipe is actually super simple… taste the piquillo pepper sauce and add salt to taste. It should look like this…
Add to your bowl of steak bites and fold the sauce throughout the mixture…
The grilled steak topping will look like this. It can be held for a full day ready to be placed on our crostini, making it a reasonably low maintenance appetizer for a cocktail party or get together.
Now when you’re ready to entertain, scoop the steak mixture onto toasted crostini and top with diced piquillo peppers. I add a sprig of thyme to each bite so they look extra pretty! Enjoy!