For the Texas Librarian's Association Conference, I was clever enough to book myself a weekend at the historic, haunted Menger Hotel in San Antonio...
Because as I always say, the BEST THING to do before a 6am national radio interview is to stay up all night, petrified that the ghost of Santa Anna is peering in at you from the closet.
Don't deny it. Santa Anna still gives you nightmares. 😀 😉
From sipping bourbon in the bar where the original Rough Riders mustered, to sleeping just steps away from the Alamo, it was a weekend I will never forget— mostly because of their signature beef tortilla soup.
At the hotel's exquisite lunch buffet, tucked into a daily smorgasbord of herbed roast beef with horseradish and rosemary aus jus, poached brown shrimp with jalapeno tartar sauce, and Tex Mex enchiladas, I found the tastiest tortilla soup I've ever had in my life.
Instead of the classic chicken tortilla soup, the Menger Hotel brings us this beef tortilla soup with traditional accompaniments.
Warning: You will not be able to stop eating it.
I rushed home to create the recipe, and here it is, just in time for Halloween!
After you cook it, it sits patiently on the stove, getting better by the minute until you're ready to chow down... which makes it a perfect choice for dinner after trick or treating, or any time you need a delicious and impressive meal, prepared ahead of time.
Enjoy! And keep an eye out for the ghost of Santa Anna— because this is one soup you'll want to return from the afterlife for!
Beef Tortilla Soup From The Menger Hotel
Ingredients
- 1 lb. ground beef 90/10 or leaner preferred because you do not drain the grease.
- 1 t. kosher salt
- 1 white onion small dice
- 2 poblano peppers seeds and white membranes removed, small diced
- 4 large garlic cloves pressed
- 6 oz. can organic tomato paste
- 2 hot house tomatoes small dice
- ½ T. Mexican oregano regular oregano is not a substitute!
- ½ t. cumin
- 1 t. Gebhardt’s or Mexene chili powder
- 2 quarts beef stock kitchen basics brand or bone stock preferred
- 2 T. fresh cilantro chopped
- ½ T. kosher salt
- ½ t. pepper
- 1 lime juiced
- 2 t. cornstarch mixed into equal parts water as a slurry
- 10 corn tortillas
- A small skillet or sauce pan filled half way with oil for frying the tortillas into tortilla strips.
- Garnishments: Corn tortillas fried into tortilla strips crumbled queso fresco, additional cilantro and limes, some people enjoy avocado cubes or fresh guacamole and sour cream.
Instructions
- In a heavy-bottomed large stockpot or dutch oven, brown the beef over medium-high heat, breaking it up with a wooden spatula. Sprinkle with salt.
- When the meat is browned, add the diced onions and poblanos, stirring them in well. Cook 4-5 minutes, reducing the heat if necessary to soften the vegetables.
- Add the garlic and tomatoes, stir well and continue to cook down for 4-5 minutes. Add the cumin, chili powder, Mexican oregano, and additional salt and pepper.
- Add in the tomato paste and stir well to incorporate. Cook 1 min. Add in the beef stock. Stir well, add cilantro and place the lid on the stockpot. Heat to medium and cook 12-20 minutes, stirring twice during cooking.
- Prepare the garnishes now.
- For the tortilla strips: Cut the corn tortillas into thin ribbons. Heat the oil over medium-high heat. Fry one handful at a time in the oil until the strips are crispy and golden brown. Remove to a plate lined with paper towels to drain and salt well. Repeat with the remaining tortilla strips.
- Remove the lid and stir well. Stir in the cornstarch slurry, whisking well. If the mixture is not boiling let the soup return to a boil, so that it may thicken with the slurry.
- Finish with the juice of a lime and season to taste.
- Serve in individual bowls topped with the fried tortilla strips, and any additional garnishes of your choosing.
frank says
This tastes exactly like the soup at the menger hotel.
The RyDogg says
delicious soup and will definitely be added to the rotation. But may Texans forgive my silly Californian sensibilities for isn't this soup just basically watered down chili?
Kathy R says
This sounds delicious!
Unrelated to soup but the very best coffee I ever had was at the Menger restaurant, still searching for something that rivals it.
Barbara Cullen Hobbs says
This might be the first recipe I have seen in a long time for tortilla soup made with burger meat but I would like someone in Texas to please locate the 1990’s Cyclone Anaya’s Mexican Restaurant (Houston, TX at their now closed Richmond Avenue location near Woodlake Square) that used to serve a similar version except it was made with high quality fajita beef strips. We used to call it our favorite tequila hangover cure because if you were sick with flu or nursing a bad weekend hangover, it was the best cure ever. They served large strips of beef fajita meat in broth with corn tortilla crispy strips, chunks of avocado, diced tomatoes and onions, cilantro, garlic, and topped with bits of queso fresco and a tiny dollop of sour cream. The crunchy corn fried tortilla strips sprinkled on top with these other items made for such a popular dish, they sold it in large stryofoam to go cups with lids to take home & enjoy. I wish someone connected to the original place had held onto this recipe. The Houston current locations only sell chicken tortilla soup - not even the same as this 1990’s salty beef fajita strip soup and I’ll bet it beats the Menger Hotel recipe too!
royce watts says
Sarah, this recipe for beef tortilla soup is fantastic. I usually make some variation with ancho, pasilla or guajillo chiles and chicken. I'll be making the Menger version much more often. I strayed from the recipe as written only minorly: charring the poblanos, using fire roasted crushed tomatoes (didn't have fresh ones)
and adding a bit more cumin and TBP New Mexican red chile powder in addition to Mexene's. I like it a bit
more spicy than most. I got a tip from a well known Houston mexican establishment to add a corn tortilla
while the chiles and broth in a blender. I just tossed a corn tortilla in while simmering and and I liked the
complexity of taste it provided. In short, your recipe is a killer without my small changes and I appreciate
it.
April Keaton says
Your Dr. Pepper taco soup is always a #1 hit in our house full of picky kids. Its absolutely their most favorite dish!! I'm asked weekly for it. Can't wait to try the Merger tortilla. We stayed there several years ago and I was not lucky enough to try it so now I am super excited to get the chance
Thank you so much for sharing!!
Sarah Penrod says
Hi April,
I LOVE that Dr.Pepper taco soup too! Hope you enjoyed this recipe.I just had a friend attend a Christmas party at the Menger and I would not stop texting her to get a bowl of this soup "to-go" from the hotel restaurant! It's so delish!